Friday, June 20, 2014

Hey! These fields are in the Historic District!

Laura C. Ricketts with the Mt. Lebanon Historic Preservation Board have prepared a 151 page registration form to the United States Department of the Interior, National Park Service. On Page 10 of National Register of Historic Places, Main Park is considered a contributing site to the Mt. Lebanon Historic District.

The Mt. Lebanon Historic District also contains three substantial greenspaces within its boundary. The northernmost is the 76-acre Mt. Lebanon Cemetery, which was established in 1874 and includes a late nineteenth century caretaker’s house as part of its property (Photograph 34)... Main Park, a 51-acre park located off Cedar Boulevard, was already established during the period of significance though the original bath house and swimming pool that were formerly located at the center of the park are no longer extant. The park itself, which features ball fields, playgrounds, and basketball and tennis courts, is considered a contributing site, but the recreation center, tennis center, and current pool house that have been built within the park after the period of significance are considered non-contributing buildings. The 42-acre Bird Park, which is located off Beadling Road, is considered a contributing site. Though it wasn’t dedicated as a named park until 1967, historical mapping and aerial photographs show that the parkland remained undeveloped through the period of significance. Bird Park consists of wooded steep terrain with a stream channel, nature trails, athletic fields, and picnic pavilions.
Why does this remind me of our trip to Doubleday Field? Doubleday Field is a baseball stadium in Cooperstown, New York. It was named for Abner Doubleday and is located near the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum. Baseball history buffs would never settle for artificial turf in Cooperstown, NY. Historians will tell you that ball fields were always grass, never plastic.

According to the Integrity Statement, "an inventory of the 4,263 resources within the 1,306-acre historic district identifies 3,344 contributing buildings, 882 non-contributing buildings, 24 contributing sites, 10 non-contributing sites, and 3 non-contributing structures."

What this tells me is that there are 3,344 buildings with standing. I learned about "standing" when I challenged Kristen Linfante's nomination petition back in 2011. You see, since I am a Republican and she is a Democrat, I had no standing. I was not permitted to challenge her nomination petition. I am not an attorney, but up until now, the only residents who had standing over this turf project were the immediate neighbors on Vee Lynn, Cedar, and Mayfair.

If anyone within the 1,306-acre historic district has an issue with plastic grass being installed on historic fields, take action! You won't see artificial turf at Doubleday Field and we shouldn't have it on our historic fields either.

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

The historic integrity of the ball fields located at Wildcat/Middle, as a major feature of Main Park and one of only three substantial green spaces within the entire historic district, will be forever altered by the proposed addition of crumb rubber and synthetic turf.

Anonymous said...

That's a reach, the football field is in that district as well.

Lebo Citizens said...

Umm, I'm not so sure, Dave.
Elaine

Anonymous said...

12:19 am

The grounds of the high school building and later additions to the campus (i.e., crumb rubber stadium) are jointly considered a non-contributing site due to a loss of integrity.

Anonymous said...

There are three greens spaces within the district but one of them is the Mt Lebanon Cemetery. Thus, there are only 2 recreational green spaces in the district.

SAB/Turf Task Force: Donnellen states that you have "unanimously" voted to add carpet to 1 of 2 beautiful green spaces in our historical district. Is this true? "Unanimously"?

Anonymous said...

Hey June 21, 2014 at 12:19 AM , the high school stadium complex is noncontributing per page 10 of the application, Dave. Deal with the facts and do not subject us to your obvious bias !

Anonymous said...

“Historic designation is associated with average property value increases ranging between approximately 5 per cent and 20 per cent of the total property value.”

“Historic Preservation and Residential Property Values: An Analysis of Texas Cities,” Leichenko, Coulson and Listokin, Urban Studies, 2001

(from a report by the HPB)

So if Wildcat/Middle are turfed, and the Cedar folks look their inclusion in the historic district, they get the double financial whammy. They lose out on the historic district increase in property value and they get hammed by living across the street from crumb rubber fields.

Nice "crown jewel", Commissioners.

Anonymous said...

Only one historic register property has been delisted in PA and it is located in Castle Shannon. They tore down an old-fashioned, innocent teen-friendly dance club along the trolley line and put in night club.

It was probably Brumfield's idea.